Why qui gon did not disappear

So he disappeared. If he learned from the rest of them after he died, how did he manage to not disappear when he first died? Did he get a time machine and go back to keep from disappearing? You are the one confusing it. Yoda and Obi knew the secret before they died, and they disappeared. Eh, I disagree.

He has talked about not caring so much about things like 3-PO having seen Owen before in comparison to things involving what he considers relevant to the themes of the saga.

It would be appreciated. Darth Jello we will find out, and according to rick mccallum, the reasoning will piss of every fan of the EU Rogue Jedi there has already been a thread about this. The Ones i know why. But in ANH when OB1 does it, Vader is surprised by it and even goes to check the clothes to see if it's not a visual trick. Therefor, it is something Vader doesn't know, and since he was a jedi, he knows the "tricks".

So it's something new, something that they didn't tell him and quite possibly prophecy related. Ushgarak Yup sorry Ones, that idea doesn't even approach the truth. The Ones oh it boggles my mind Ushgarak No, afraid not, suffers from the same problem, RJ. As has been made clear, it is notrhing to do with how powerful, skilled or prepared you are. Jedi have never done it before. It is a plot point specific to the storyline of the prequel films. Rogue Jedi well, gimmee a better theory and convince me then.

OB1 trained him, Yoda trained the one that had to redeem him and Anakin QGJ only recognised him, he never trained him Rogue Jedi its too much Shadowkiller I hope we will find out. I have no theroies as to why he didn't dissapear. Clearly it's something Jedi had never done before the OT If memory serves me right, he was even asked to be on the Jedi Council once or twice Rogue Jedi well. Rogue Jedi well, if GL says so, then i guess we have to go with that.

QGJ is the link. Anakin2Vader Just wondering why everyone is so sure Vader didnt know about this ability? It seems to me that he knew of it because he himself used it. As he dies in front of Luke he suddenly remembers "Oh man, I SO forgot about this neato trick, oh wow now I can give it a try - here I come - wheeee! Deflok Remember Anakin's line in Ep2 about learning how to stop people from dying? Well maybe this life after death as a Jedi Spirit has something to do with it?

Just an idea I know Anakin was having a moment but for some reason I think Lucas really wanted us to remember Anakin saying that. Rogue Jedi Ushgarak Far from impossible indeed- but that makes it look somewhat conscious from Anakin, which would be odd. Lyn I thought there must be some significance to that line also, the whole idea about Anakin promising his mother that he'd never let it happen again.

Ushgarak Errr I repeat what I said. Rogue Jedi i think it was just annie feeling the power of the dark side, which he fell briefly over to while slaughtering the tuskens. Rolda Hayes Hang on a mo And how would that bridge the disappearance mystery? Rogue Jedi it was qui gon. Darth Jello the jedi use a new technique. Sith Master X Jello, you've got quite a mind!! Kaden Barcuu It was Qui Gon's voice in episode 2. Rick even said they recycled Liam's audio. And when Qui Gon says "No," Yoda is surprised.

As of the beginning of the clone wars, no Jedi knows how to maintain their "spirit" after death. It is a Sith trick.

The Sith have been doing it for thousands of years. They even know how to transfer their spirit in other bodies, as Palpatine does. I guess after the extinction of the jedi, Yoda, Obi Wan and Anakin some how learn the trick through something related to Palpatine.

A holocron or something. Lobo I think Anakin kept that promise by doing for Luke what he couldn't do for Shmi. As soon as the saber got closed he zipped away with force-induced speed, leaving his clothes there to confuzzle DV. Seriously, no. I think the prophecy theory is the best idea so far.

Rogue Jedi he did not. When he's being burnt, he's got the full uniform on. Is it possible he may have faded away when he was being brought from the Death Star to Endor when Luke was flying the lamb? I dunno. Rogue Jedi but Ush, did we see him disappear?

Sith Master X Maybe just because one is a ghost, they didn't have to have disapeared. I know there is a followed pattern like Obi-Wan and Yoda, but maybe something is missing and will be explained in Episode 3, or at least it's supposed to be explained. SMX Ushgarak The reason I say very likely as opposed to certain is precisely because we did not see it on screen, although there is good grounds to saying that being as he turned up in ghost form it makes the disappearing canon.

The reason it is very likely is because the official site stated as much when specifically asked the question. This isn't canon but it is a phenomenally good lead and it is the default way to think. Rogue Jedi its a good lead, but it wasnt in the movie. Ushgarak That seemed to be pointless repetition, RJ.

Rogue Jedi all i am saying is if you and the other mods are gonna enforce rules here, you should follow them yourselves. Crazy Frog Crazy Frog k gold badges silver badges bronze badges. Featured on Meta. Now live: A fully responsive profile. Upcoming Events. November Topic Challenge: Samuel R.

Delany ends Nov Linked Related Hot Network Questions. Accept all cookies Customize settings.